Ozone intercomparison

 
 

 

 


Introduction
Brochure
Science:
 Envisat
 Data assimilation
 Objectives
Links:
 ASSET database
 Current data
 Ozone intercomparison
Partners
Publications
Calendar
Document archive
Contacts

= ASSET members and PAG only

= ASSET members and PAG; others may request access from the coordinators

 


This page contains links to most code, data and plots associated with the ASSET intercomparison of ozone analyses.

Most of the data is made freely available for research purposes, though please note that additional restrictions apply to the use of the ECMWF analyses. Depending on which of the analyses you use, please cite the appropriate references from the list below, along with Geer et al. (2006, ACP). See the intercomparison paper for the full details of these citations.

  • ECMWF - Dethof et al. (2003)
  • BASCOE - Errera and Fonteyn (2001)
  • DARC/Met Office - Geer et al. (2006, QJ)
  • KNMI - Eskes et al. (2003) or Segers et al. (2005a)
  • Meteo France - Massart et al. (2005)
  • MIMOSA - Fierli et al. (2002)
  • Juckes - Juckes (2005)

For further information please contact Alan Geer (ageer@met.reading.ac.uk) or William Lahoz (wal@met.reading.ac.uk)

The ASSET intercomparison of ozone analyses: method and first results, 2006: A. J. Geer, W. A. Lahoz, S. Bekki, N. Bormann, Q. Errera, H. J. Eskes, D. Fonteyn, D. R. Jackson, M. N. Juckes, S. Massart, V.-H. Peuch, S. Rharmili, and A. Segers, Atmos. Chem. Phys., 6, 5445-5474.   Abstract and link to PDF

Plots

Key

Key to all line figures, also available as a ps file:

Analysis fields

SH polar stereographic plot
15th July 2003 at   800hPa: ps png   250hPa: ps png   68hPa: ps png   10hPa: ps png   2.2hPa: ps png   0.5hPa: ps png
31st Aug 2003 at   800hPa: ps png   250hPa: ps png   68hPa: ps png   10hPa: ps png   2.2hPa: ps png   0.5hPa: ps png
17th Oct 2003 at   800hPa: ps png   250hPa: ps png   68hPa: ps png   10hPa: ps png   2.2hPa: ps png   0.5hPa: ps png
15th Nov 2003 at   800hPa: ps png   250hPa: ps png   68hPa: ps png   10hPa: ps png   2.2hPa: ps png   0.5hPa: ps png

Tropical tropopause
17th Oct 2003 at   100hPa: ps png

Meaned in latitude bands versus Logan 1999 climatology (crosses) and Fortuin and Kelder 1998 climatology (dots).
Partial pressure:   July: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png
Mixing ratio:   July: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png

Ozonesonde comparisons

Zonal coverage, by month: ps png

Latitude band mean of (analysis - sonde)
Percentage:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png
Partial pressure:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png
Mixing ratio:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png

Latitude band standard deviation of (analysis - sonde)
Percentage:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png
Partial pressure:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png
Mixing ratio:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png

Time series at sonde stations
South pole:   300hPa: ps png   200hPa: ps png   100hPa: ps png   68hPa: ps png   46hPa: ps png   31hPa: ps png   21hPa: ps png   10hPa: ps png
McMurdo:   300hPa: ps png   200hPa: ps png   100hPa: ps png   68hPa: ps png   46hPa: ps png   31hPa: ps png   21hPa: ps png   10hPa: ps png
Syowa:   300hPa: ps png   200hPa: ps png   100hPa: ps png   68hPa: ps png   46hPa: ps png   31hPa: ps png   21hPa: ps png   10hPa: ps png
Ascension Island:   300hPa: ps png   200hPa: ps png   100hPa: ps png   68hPa: ps png   46hPa: ps png   31hPa: ps png   21hPa: ps png   10hPa: ps png
Nairobi:   300hPa: ps png   200hPa: ps png   100hPa: ps png   68hPa: ps png   46hPa: ps png   31hPa: ps png   21hPa: ps png   10hPa: ps png
Payerne:   300hPa: ps png   200hPa: ps png   100hPa: ps png   68hPa: ps png   46hPa: ps png   31hPa: ps png   21hPa: ps png   10hPa: ps png

Profiles at sonde stations
South pole:   2 Sep: ps png   16 Sep: ps png   29 Sep: ps png   11 Oct: ps png

Plot data: Latitude band statistics of (analysis - sonde): sonde_stats.nc

HALOE comparisons

Zonal coverage, by month: ps png

Latitude band mean of (analysis - HALOE)
Percentage:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png
Mixing ratio:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png

Latitude band standard deviation of (analysis - HALOE)
Percentage:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png
Mixing ratio:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png

Plot data: Latitude band statistics of (analysis - HALOE): haloe_stats.nc

MIPAS comparisons

Zonal coverage, by month: ps png

Latitude band mean of (analysis - MIPAS)
Percentage:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png
Mixing ratio:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png

Latitude band standard deviation of analysis - MIPAS
Percentage:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png
Mixing ratio:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png

Equator (10S-0S) standard deviation of analysis - MIPAS and analysis - sonde
Percentage:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png

Plot data: Latitude band statistics of (analysis - MIPAS): mipas_stats.nc

MIPAS calibration - using the analyses as a transfer standard

Latitude band mean of (MIPAS - analysis) - (HALOE - analysis)
Percentage:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png

Latitude band mean of (MIPAS - analysis) - (sonde - analysis)
Percentage:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png

Latitude band mean of (MIPAS - analysis) - (HALOE (dotted)/sonde(solid) - analysis); BASCOE v3q34 only
Percentage:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png

TOMS and total column comparisons

Zonal statistics of (analysis - TOMS), by month:
Mean:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png
Std. deviation:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png
Correlation:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png
Colocations:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png

Global statistics of (analysis - TOMS), as timeseries:
Mean: ps png
Standard deviation: ps png
Correlation: ps png
Colocations: ps png

Total column measures from analysis:
Ozone hole area: ps png
Minimum ozone amount: ps png

Influence of troposphere: (analysis - Logan 1999 climatology), integrated into a partial column amount from surface to 200hPa:
Mean:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png

Influence of troposphere: (analysis with Logan 1999 climatology subsituted at 200hPa and below - TOMS):
Std. deviation:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png
Correlation:   Jul: ps png   Aug: ps png   Sep: ps png   Oct: ps png   Nov: ps png   Jul-Nov: ps png   18 Aug - 30 Nov: ps png

Plot data: Zonal and global statistics of (analysis - TOMS): toms_stats.nc

Data

All data is in NetCDF format. In these files, the parameter "julian_day" contains the date and time in the format used in IDL. This is the time in days since 12UTC, 1st January 4713 B.C, including fractions of days to represent the time precisely. In this representation, 00UTC on 1st January 2000 is given by 2451544.5. Other parameters and units should be self-explanatory from the contents of the NetCDF file.

Analyses

Analysis ozone:

  • interpolated onto the common grid
  • interpolated from common grid to sonde, HALOE, and MIPAS locations
  • total columns calculated on the original analysis grid (columns only calculated for analyses that include the troposphere and lower stratosphere
ECMWF operational analyses:   ECMWF access conditions apply.
ECMWF pre-operational MIPAS analyses:   ECMWF access conditions apply.
KNMI TEMIS:  analyses  column  at sonde  at haloe  at mipas
KNMI SCIA profiles:  analyses  column  at sonde  at haloe  at mipas
BASCOE v3d24:  analyses  column  at sonde  at haloe  at mipas
BASCOE v3q31:  analyses  column  at sonde  at haloe  at mipas
Meteo France MOCAGE - Cariolle v2.1:  analyses  column  at sonde  at haloe  at mipas
Meteo France MOCAGE - Cariolle v2.1 - modified (heterogeneous depletion at zenith angles <87 degrees only) :  analyses  column  at sonde  at haloe  at mipas
Meteo France MOCAGE - Reprobus:  analyses  column  at sonde  at haloe  at mipas
Meteo France MOCAGE - 4D-var:  analyses  column  at sonde  at haloe  at mipas
UK Met Office / DARC - Unified Model:  analyses  column  at sonde  at haloe  at mipas
UK Met Office / DARC - Unified Model (Correctly implemented Cariolle scheme, October only):  analyses  column  at sonde  at haloe  at mipas
UK Met Office / DARC - Unified Model (LINOZ chemistry, October only):  analyses  column  at sonde  at haloe  at mipas
Juckes 2005:  analyses column  at sonde  at haloe  at mipas
MIMOSA:  analyses column  at sonde  at haloe  at mipas
Combined Logan 1999 and Fortuin and Kelder 1998 climatology:  analyses column  at sonde  at haloe  at mipas
Randel 1998 ozone from UARS MLS and HALOE, mapped by ECMWF PV equivalent latitude:  analyses column  at sonde  at haloe  at mipas

Independent data

The original indepdendent data files can be downloaded from the TOMS, HALOE, SHADOZ, WOUDC and NDSC websites. MIPAS data can be obtained via ESA.

Observational data pre-processed for use in the ASSET intercomparison is available to ASSET project members, those that contact the ASSET PI and ask for access, but in the case of MIPAS data, only those who are allowed access via an ESA AO project.

Independent data on original levels:
Ozone sonde:  asset_2003.nc readme file 
HALOE:  haloe_asset.nc 
MIPAS:  mipas_asset_o3.nc 

Independent data interpolated onto the common pressure levels:
Ozone sonde:  sonde_on_clev.nc 
HALOE:  haloe_on_clev.nc 
MIPAS:  mipas_on_clev.nc 

Climatology

Logan (1999) and Fortuin and Kelder (1998) climatologies combined and meaned in latitude bands. These are the values used in the calculation of normalised statistics: banded_logan_fk_clev.nc

Code

All IDL code used in the intercomparison is listed here. The top-level program is asset_run.pro. In the interpolation of analysis data to the common grid, and the interpolation of independent data to common levels, there are dependencies on many data files that are not supplied on this website. However, all operations on the common-gridded data should work.

Code directory

Tar file containing all code